ࡱ> ]_\q` RJbjbjqPqP8\::D^^^8L<D%**"LLL'''$$$$$$$$'hl)v$!V''VV$LL$ VLL$ V$ ""L d^"$%0D%",)p)")"'>e, $'''$$ j'''D%VVVVD^^ _lDelphi method N0MR (Wnje Nb`l*gw N ˊ\[cOvQ\miw0}WSa NQZvQ \yr[pLvqQX0,gel \eRgܖOUL0U0Osr0cf?eV{TꌌTmiRIWv:eI{ /fN.z gHe]wQ0_l/fN.zƖ`^vOc,n*gOsavel /f)R(uN#2N g|q}vOUwS _bxvzOUL gܕv\[x[a0(W?S TS|_dk Nb \bv`l N 2LxeVTvOUwSg Nk!kg_RgP}g# TeOUwSQRT\[ \OpOckHQMRavS YdkS2Lv0RT\[va]puMgNOpbk /SƖb_bN'`wQԚvqQX0vQ|QwQgpTPq}OUwSgl*Qޞ /f^z(W 0P}iSvnj Am 00 0?S TvԚzl[ 0T 0\[$Re 0vSt N0Pq}vOUwSgS|vN!kOUwS1\[bg]\O _lGR|vN#2N[ƖvOUwSMb[bgxvz TBf&NcOY!kvVKa wQn\O(u0vQt֊Wy/f1uN\[x[D}bvxvz\D} (Wxe!kOUwSkXT{_ a NNv\[S9eSHQva TYxe\[kXT{va V O'YYxev\[eY!kOUwS\OT{_ a8oTeN sSS2L_~vRg0N N\R%R1\_lKNwkSwnSvQvܕek_ZPf0 N0_lvwkSwn N CQMR ~ 0Delphi 0dkW[neS ^؁v TW P*Y}^y?lAppol Pythios fE\OO(WdkW??l^ykKNOmphalosw N0/fN.z^[-Nc,n*gOv]wQ geO(ue,nvP}g Ee 0Delphi 0^y gNh0,nKNa0 N 1950t^NRg ~ 1950t^NRgp_lxvza(uvo0 Wͅ_lQSRand Corporation HQ|vU\Q_bSDelphi Technique vuBfͅ_lQS(W Wzz͎v R N_NN W2xvz \vQ}T Tp_kuProject Delphi 0ku/fO(uN#2N^l[ƖOUwS &NNc6RVKfeedback nj ggN\[a No0beu-vޞ aϑqvv W͎]mivgsO;edvj &N0O@bvSP[H_xev NMNO͎Tvxeϑ Ʌ1uY_Ɩ\[vNa d[VaOv0beuR0  N 1960-1970t^N ~ 1960t^N-Ng HelmerSGorden|vhReport on a Long Range Forecasting Study HQ\_l_(ue͎NNYvW ]0FUmiLuOY8oa(u(WOmiTNRva O ?e^_jܕ0x[S_ji_NK(udklZP?eV{U0Ovel01970t^N \BvOePOULGRYK(u&N2L,n0 N0_lK(uKN } _l gN NmQ PV }ib_lv } N \[\D}expert panel \[vD}bzl[_lxvzvgB}P}g0Vdk\D}bTvtx`Svvu͑vbV01ue/fݑ \Sp;NLc @bNa gT.z N T̀of0W0}WvNXS0 N O^reliability SHe^validity @bO^ /fcaϑ]wQvckx'`accuracy b|xprecision 0O^Nhva gNiz['`stability TN'`consistency 0@bHe^ c,nϑ]wQwck,nQxvz;NLv z^0N Po}Yv]wQa g YvO^He^0(W_lxvzN z-N Vc͑e,n&NNNVKc6R SNMQN]puv|vu @bNO^SHe^STvvu4ln0  N ?S TSGRanonymity pMQWԚ-N\Nir_w_>wHeabandwagon effect SZ k_ g_authoritarian submission I{_tV } GRc(u?S Te_O\[\D}bT1uhTa &N\Q N Td\!kvϑ Oh:yQv wl|QwQlQs^'`0 V VKc6Rfeedback control _l \xvz]wQKNO(u N TeN,OUwSvUTn0e,{NVT\[OUwSV6e_ xvzNTsSY2Lq}]\O &Ne,{NVTOUwSHTsQ,{NVT-N\[ PNKN wlS\D}KNaR vv(WeO\[Pw] N!kvkXT{gQ[TԚ-NKNkXT{PT0/f\[vSYaԚa NN FO/f_O \Ԛah:y T Se N!kkXT{OUwSBfOcka0P\[ \]SHQahTXcz4X NSN(W N!kOUwS-NsSV /fxvzKN|^y@b(W SNƖ`^vSSN}c\[hsz$RevR0 N N'`consensus _l/fNyx[ve_Y_te\[va NS_qQ Tv wl OS-rp'`v;NLrs_qQX0 mQ xvz҉rvnbothe role of the researcher xvz gN \\[㉪_lvvv z^ O\[ \xvz;NLcO PN ٖecNRT\Oe_0 Couper1984 pWn[b_lxvz g N PW,gϑ1 YvBf02 SwQ gf[hTTSq}vR NSoSvSRaX03 0OUwSv}6RN Y\&NteTSapSGR0Vdk8^O(u_lt֊2L֊N PbY P NRyr'` R%Rp 10 Nfx'`vuOUL!qlO(ufxvRgbS FO Y}1u(WqQ TWy N;N$ReOzl[0 20ܖ'` \e;NLX[(W^l'`vq_mSYd\bNR0 30_>w'`YSKN PNb \bNAmNRfp gHe N֊HegɅ1uWԚn z^ cGS0 40-r֊'` PN-r֊g_V͑ n z^_O(uNb?S T0 50s[ϑBfTё"OWԚgp L NSL0 Vdk YjwkSNNva0c^S0W@SRxd0R!hWS z[c0ܖ}ob>ygsavVgܕO0֊ PNPygvjUOE\HQI{I{KNxvz GWi(u_l0 V0DelphiOUwS-0njetetSq}Rg N OUwS- Delphi,n gN Pvvu'Yv*QR sS N(u0Rؚmvq}el _N1\/fdkl NP(Wx[SW-NO(uNSK(u(WOmiLuI{0DelphiOUwS-Bfc(uV.zel >e_OUL 8^(u(W,{NVTOUwSBf xvz\D}NTN>e_e_\[1\xvz;NL,g1u|vha dk vv(We NOPvQ`{ W _N1\/fƖ>w^zf0(W,{NVTOUwS_ xvzNT}gQ[Rgcontent analysis \\[axk^ |vU\,{NVTOUwS0  0/fb&T 0NRl (W,{NVTN_ O@bP}ga(u N TUϑel0 0/fb&T 0NRlpvQ-NN.z ;N/fˊ\[ \;NLh:y 0 b 0b 0S \ 00 0ar 0b 0 Nar 00 0SN 0b 0 NSN 0I{a ^wYv-NxQ 0͑ 0v &NcR,{N͑b,{N͑^ NOcSceBfS*QHQt^SvOd0vQ!k/fU0OqQX'`/f&T"uu Nzl[_lxvz/f&T|~~2L0N NiQ]\O gN Nc'`q}e_HTsWԚa0 x[͑'`vS͑'`c^iz['`  &*.0 < > x  h ®vhvZL>0hijhjXOJPJQJo(hijh.NhOJPJQJo(hijh(bOJPJQJo(hijhOJPJQJo(hijhS OJPJQJo(hijhyNOJPJQJo(hijhLOJPJQJo(hijhZ`OJPJQJo(hijhn1OJPJQJo(&hijhn15CJ$OJPJQJaJ$o(&hijhZm5CJ$OJPJQJaJ$o(&hijh~5CJ$OJPJQJaJ$o()hijhn15CJ$OJPJQJ\aJ$o(&0    ,fhb$hdhWD`ha$gd$} $dha$gdm $dha$gd, $dha$gdK6$dhWD`a$gdv $dha$gd8f$dhWD`a$gd NRIJ     dzvfXXJ<@BF(,fjBDHr 622չեュugeUhijh~OJPJQJo(hijh3.OJPJQJo(&hijh~5CJ$OJPJQJaJ$o(hijhFbOJPJQJo(&hijhn15CJ$OJPJQJaJ$o(hijhPZOJPJQJo(hijhOJPJQJo(hijhT=OJPJQJo(hijhn1OJPJQJo(hijh*"OJPJQJo('(fBDr,.<h $dha$gdQ$dhVDWD^`a$gdOy $dha$gd&a $dha$gdi$dhWD`a$gdv$dhWD`a$gdFb$dhVDWDj^`a$gdh  6b5d5|5L6<8>8R88899$hdhWD`ha$gd-A $dha$gd" $dha$gd: $dha$gdQ$dhWD`a$gdv$hxdhVDWD2^h`xa$gdOypO,gxvzP}gfwQ g[(u'` \\[aNLikert}T:\^aϑ\[v:ya z^0b͑'`bTi'`Rb00R5 Pd\} R%Rf}NU[Rxe0-5R0RxeaؚsSh:ya͑baTi0NƖ-NRϑxeRgOBl_Tvvs^GWxemean T>wxemode wnjevƖ-NR sSw\[ \Tv͑'`vU0O`b_0{Ss^GWxe/fN P gHe NOPvNhxe FOYgxed-NQs Nck8^vui'Ywxe0ND},nwxe0>wxe8^MOe,nwxe NSxed-N g Nck8^ui'Ybui\wxeiT['`xedvc0/fEe vuNL*gTaNjnBf SNOUwSvteԚiz[ z^\Opg/f&TP}_gvzl[Od Franchack, Desy & Norton1984 \iz[^v wl vuMR_VTvas^GWxevs^GWwNvqQX _Nrs_>wNv/ec0 0}c\[hsz$RevRdk.zbSe_ Y_[fTbWԚNva 2bk \z bONNvXR VdkS֊WԚbTh:yaBf Nga0RZ O\[Ochsz$RevR0 0Sb4xBfzz▄vVX )Rexvz2LzlRUT0W !qlJZNXb \b֊nvOUL0 0 N)R(uܖvq}_lP)R(uc'`q}o:y\[vN'`ce'` Na(u0RؚI{ܖvq}bS0 0eLel^8^!|U NwkSnje0 0(We,nvN z-N k PpLrs_o^von VdkUNVTOUwSv _lvP}gS fteԚa-N0}_v]pu0 0Ʌ1uN!k!k0|q}Svg NSaOP]vSOck g_Srs_~^NNNh@b g\[avP}g0 6q _lN!qSMQ0WgS0RvQNV }r^d Sb N :ޞ 0*gna NSevNN_lP1\*gONNZPS|vuv$ReU0O !qlna NSgNN0 0_l_N\[PvvwX xvzP}g{S[fS0R\[,g;N$Revr^d0 0 \e!jziQSvOULNRRN[ wl\[̀of0}W N T \ TN;NL g N Tv wl gBf*QޞsSp:ޞ :ޞsSp*Qޞ N܈bHe0 0\[Nh'` NS֊vbTxd Ns^GW OP\g"uu OY1uN PNYNSvWԚ@bcQv*QRaBf Sg]Ste PxvzP}gvxd0 0Bf[OUwS_ԏBfNw ]NAS)YN N[b S֊vbTSVdk1YSRR OUwSV6es Nؚ gO_P}gva N'Y01ue_lv2L8^VOUwSvY!k_ԏ BfR OUwSV6esaOaNO Vdk|vU\Q 0OckW_l 0modified Delphi method 0@b 0OckW_l 0/fdS_lv|^y*Qޞ bA~ܖvOUwS2LN z!|S 8^vOcke_ giQ.z 0weu,{NVT>e__bvek_ NO(u>e_OUwS_b\[a /fOde{s-NvܕxvzP}gbxvzv}WdQTv Qˊ\[Odd[vhT PNa dkOckelSNn\VSNVT{>e_OUwS MNOOUwSV6es0 0TuO,{ NVT,{VVT xvzN zS g N Pk \,{NVTtetvP}g[f}\[ ˊvQOgqxvzvR^v2L 0͑'` 0S 0I{} 0Uϑ n\\[Q!k[av_jg0 0Lanford1972 cQ (WNOck__l@b2Lxvz-N fov\[aZTsa8^Qs(W,{N0NVTKN0VdkOck__l\2LiQ PVTg FOgY8^(WV PVTgQ OST0R\[qQXbaviz[^0 mQ0P} _l(W-zRvjvR7_ FOVBfR SVOUwS_ԏxe!kvkXT{ EeSwQ gvvuvq__0S/fe g\miwXcQa NFOScOvQNS\[Q^`v_jg &NSNvSNNvaO \gq]v\OT{ #jvNR gReSݑ \e[pL ZPQevP}OUL͑'`v`cR f2NekTN'`vqQX0OUwS N@bR vq}nje eSq}TԚ`vP}gT fSR\[1\vQ\whTa0 NFOSmdPq}_b \bFUNJ@b_wv_tVXY SNcfN'`qQXvT0FON gvQP6R (W\[xd N 1ueN,xdwQ gP[x[ b g}WvNX __ b\[ T'`ؚ S:ON N Tv [f bSuONsa q_V6es Vdk(WO(u_l N/fyr%Rlav0We0 njeOn RgaɄ2001 wggqwOKNR NDelphi Techniques W2x[blQqQ[uxvz@bxX֊e0 Blow, A.J.  Sprenkle, D.H.2001 Common Factor Across Theories of Marriage and Family TherapyA Modified Delphi Study. Journal of Marital and Family Theorpy. 27(3), p385-401. Delbecq, A.L., Van de Ven, A.H.  Gustafson,D.H.1986 Group Techniques for Program PlanningA guide to nominal group and Delphi processes. Green Briar Press. Linstone, H.A.  Murray Turoff1975 The Delphi MethodTechniques and Applications. Addison-Wesley Publishing Company.     >ygxvzel\L ZSNs5_ \O x[ _92103903 PAGE  PAGE 1 2366889999 ::::::6;8;:;;;;<<<パuuugYKhijh?JOJPJQJo(hijhAROJPJQJo(hijhknOJPJQJo(hijhEOJPJQJo(hijhd%OJPJQJo(hijh6^OJPJQJo(hijh-AOJPJQJo(&hijhn15CJ$OJPJQJaJ$o(&hijh~5CJ$OJPJQJaJ$o(hijh:OJPJQJo(hijhn1OJPJQJo(hijhQOJPJQJo(99 ::6;;;<<<<$=2===`>>\@@4APA$dhVDWD^`a$gdgF) $dha$gd:g$dhWD`a$gdv$3dhWD@^`3a$gdv $dha$gd$><<<$=4=6===`>d>>>^@`@6A8A^A`AAABBBBBB㝏{gS&hijh\65CJ$OJPJQJaJ$o(&hijh&N5CJ$OJPJQJaJ$o(&hijh~5CJ$OJPJQJaJ$o(hijhXpOJPJQJo(hijhOJPJQJo(hijh:gOJPJQJo(hijhE&OJPJQJo(hijh6^OJPJQJo(hijhRbOJPJQJo(hijhn1OJPJQJo(hijh6rOJPJQJo(PAABBBBJELEVEE(GdHPIRIVIXI\I^IbIdI $dha$gdb $dha$gd\6$dhWD`a$gdv$dhWD^`a$gdgF)$dhVDWD^`a$gdgF)BBCCBD2E4E8EjhO>UhijhOJPJQJ^Jo(hijhw+3OJPJQJ^Jo(hijhubOJPJQJ^Jo(hijhw+3OJPJQJo(hijhubOJPJQJo(hijhsbOJPJQJ^Jo(hijhsbOJPJQJo(hijhn1OJPJQJo(dIhIjIIfJhJzJ|J~JJJJJJ$dhWD`a$gdv&`#$ r gdq IIIIIIIIIJJJ4J@JBJfJhJjJvJxJzJ~JJJJJJJJJJ༨xtdhijhOJPJQJ^Jo(hO>h N0JmHnHu h*0Jjh*0JUh* h*>*CJOJQJ^JaJo(&h:~h*>*CJOJQJ^JaJo("h:~h*>*CJOJPJaJo(#h:~h*CJOJQJ^JaJo(h:~h*CJOJPJaJo(h*CJOJQJ^JaJo(61h2P:p1. A!"#$%S H@H gQe1$$CJKHPJ_HaJmH nHsH tH$A@$ -k=W[WFiF h\ 9r G$CJaJ)@ x\ ~34@Tj ( DEm!Kg! " 9 A  s  L M Y qx6b-4c5C@AF~/CDGJMPI0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I0I00000000000000000000000I00I00I00I00@0@0I00`I00I00@0@0I00   <2<BEIJ&(*+-bh9PAdIJ'),J!!t8@0(  B S  ?@tAl!B<|}C]|9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsplace8*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsCity }  %*+23@Hio} )24?@SU\j# ( CFQm "JLfh " $ * 8 : @ G {   r s y       ; = K M X Y m 4:@AHKQWps prwx56ab,.34bc45BC?AEFJOZk}/6EHOPQ^DDFFGGIJLMOP KPqr$(ILXYwz   . 1 = > l m kn#)VZ-Z^DDFFGGIJLMOPs33333sss3ssss333s3sss3333s3sssss333333ss3s33333333 CDDFFGGIJLMOPDDFFGGIJLMOPQE6\b ^` o( ^` 0 ^` . ^` .`  ` ^` ` 0@  @ ^@ ` .   ^ ` . ^` 0 ^` .QE"d        hgOy]u pSd%iS L&sf(gF)$-3.n1w+3K6\6P7O>-%A-A 5B_I?J N&NVPQWjXXF[\6^7`Z`&ab6bFbsbub1h.NhijXp4uvvxm,z$}~:~PZEomZmRb}XIS/q-9$>E&B6r>i1T=::g!4L++[*"y eAR,~Z*yN, W<(b8fE:kn"@T PP2UnknownGz Times New Roman5Symbol3& z Arial_  (^N[ԚW4(P)Arial Unicode MS/E .jwiԚ5& zaTahomaC.e0}fԚPMingLiU 1hFFx *x *Y?!),.:;?]}    " % & ' 2 t%00 0 0 00000013468:<>@BDOPQRTUVWZ\^ \]d([{  5 0 0 00000579;=?ACY[][d99  2QHP?F[2_lDelphi method nhiuser chen li-hsing Oh+'0   @ L Xdlt|wk]Delphi method^nhiuserNormalchen li-hsing2Microsoft Office Word@@XҺ@XҺx՜.+,0 X`px nhitb* 9   !"#$%&'()*+,-.012345689:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKMNOPQRSUVWXYZ[^Root Entry F١`Data /1Table7)WordDocument8\SummaryInformation(LDocumentSummaryInformation8TCompObjm  FMicrosoft Office Word MSWordDocWord.Document.89q