ࡱ> sur` RPbjbjss2bZ%RRR \ ,!!!8("4\"T,iJ""""""W8W8W8IIIIIII$cKhMJ![:2W8[:[:Jhh""#J+G+G+G[:h""I+G[:I+G+GXII"" $y!C4pII9J0iJxI,uN9FuNIuNI8W8v8T+G!9De9W8W8W8JJFdW8W8W8iJ[:[:[:[:,,,!,,,!,,,hhhhhh  PHhxvzl000000000000 ; 1XJT}                            PHhxvzlcase study method N0MR PHhxvz/f2L>ygyx[xvzvelKNN яt^O PHhxvz(W>ygyx[xvz#l8ovL N YxeW@bK(u vQ-NSbNPq}vx[y_tx[0>ygx[0?elx[0N^x[0wkSx[NS}ox[ _NSb[R\TW Y>yg]\O0Ye0lQqQL?e0lQqQ?eV{0{tyx[0NS]kuI{01ue PHhxvz__}TK(uT.zxvzel O2Lnje6eƖv]\O Mb \xvzsa2LhQ_vN0Vdk N N\ \ PHhxvzlKNW,gi_0xvz-laN0njeƖKNelRg0NS PHhxvzv*Q:ޞI{ ZPNN9}f0 N0 PHhxvzvW,gi_ N PHhxvzv[ (W[ PHhxvzKNMR \e@bKN 0 PHh 0GRHQc(uYin1994 N 0RgvUMO 0unit of analysis \ PHhRNLu[sSxvzvRgUMO/fN PN0N PD}T~0N P>y@S0N P W[& .I{  PN0D}T~0>y@S0 W[1\/f 0 PHh 00!|KN PHh@bc&N NPPeN PN0e 0 PHhxvz 0KN[pUOR RgY N 1.Merriam1998 \e PHhxvzv[ GRcSkevKa^ pS/f \N P gLuPv|q} YeHh0_ji0 PԚ0[^0>y@SbQg=I{ ZPhQ_vcTRg 1\/f@bv PHhxvz0 2.Feagin0OrumSjoberg1991 NN \ PHhxvzv[/fcK(u'`xvzvel ݑ \UN>ygsa2Lm^ShQb_vcN z0 3.9hd>yg]\OxQ2000 v[ 0 PHhxvz 0/fc 0NgN P>ygUCQ\OpN PteԚ@b_Nvxvz @b_NxvzKNUCQS/fN PN0N P[^0N PWԚ0N P_jܕ0N P>y@S0N P0W@SbN P W[ 00 4.Xomn2003246 \ PHhxvz[pN.z P%Rv0m^v0cj~v NOPTꌄvN.zxvzel vQ@bxvzvUMO NN[N PNpP SNdU\[^0_ji0eSWԚ ute P>y@S0vQ@bcnjeSY!k}vGWS `_Oxk }0Rg0OUwS0gNJO[Sbhc 1uewQ gsvmeQvRHe @bNcQwQԚ S gHevUtel /f>ygxvzelvN.z0 N PHhxvzvvvI͑e 2001198-199 001.~bQOULvSV \NNNbLp NZP PHhxvz_㖆NvQ|vuvwckSV OYx[uwPzLp }1u PHhxvzKN_1\S|vsSV NN &N~bQwckSV0 002.cQzlOULvel PHhxvz(W~bQOULwckSVKN_ 1\ScQzlOULv \V{0 003.cO2ce PHhxvz YmeQcOUL |vsOULv9h,gSV #j1\ Y9hdSV cQ2{ce0 004.cfD}T~_jiv>~Hevu PHhxvzND}T~_ji\OpxvzUCQBf SN:evQ}q{t Nv:1Y 2 cQ9e2eHh ͑cD}T~bTX#l cfD}T~v>~Hez-rR0  N PHhxvzv^W 001.O PHhxvzvvSRpc"}W0cW0ˑWI{ N^WKN PHhxvzs#k 84160Xomn 2003257-258 1 c"}'`v PHhxvzxvzvv;N/fW͑e \OULvLu[ b/fzl[xvzek_vSL'`0;N/fUt 0/fNwhat 0b__ gܕ0 2 cWv PHhxvzxvzvv;N/f \xvzsava} 2Lsvv0[tevc Ut 0who 0UOUwhere 0vOUL gܕ0 003 ˑWv PHhxvzxvzvv;N/fݑ \xvznje 2LVgܕOvxˑ Ut 0YUOhow 0pUOwhy 0vOUL gܕ0 002.O Pxvz \axeϑSRpUN PHh0Y͑ PHhXomn 2003255-256 0 001 UN PHhc(Wte PxvzN z-N xvz;N/fݑ \N P PԚ0[^0WԚb>y@S 2Lxvz gܕnje6eƖv]\O0 2 Y͑ PHh/fc(Wte PxvzN z-N xvz TBfݑ \~^ P0[^0WԚb>y@S 2Lxvz gܕnje6eƖv]\O vuxvz TBfݑ \N PbN PN Nv PHh2Lxvz 1\1zKNpY͑ PHhxvz0 V PHhxvzvyr_Feagin et al.,1991I͑e 2002197 giOt 2000243-244 1.(W6q`X NcvzOUL PHhxvzlvQNxvzelg'Yv N T (Wexvz Y2eQxvz \avu;m4XW (W Nr^dxvz \a6q` N 2L gܕxvzsabLR[0 002.meQsv PHhxvz NP ghbv[ N gm^vc0 003.^it֊ PHhxvzl;N/fK(uxk }/`}O2Lxvz (WxvzN z@b6eƖ0Rv[Pnje xvz\gK(uxk }0k0 \gqI{e_2LnjeRg g_|vU\Qet_be`} &N\Op^it֊vWy0 004.NYCQel6eƖ PHhnjepmeQ PHhKNxvz vQnjev6eƖelvvuYCQ SbeN0jHh}0[0*NJI{0 5.hsyr'` PHhxvz^8^͑k P PHhvhsyr'` 7_k PxvzvsabLR gvQhsyr'` @bNxvz_meQN㉫xvz`X0NN0eHhTsa ̀_@bHTsKNapUO0 N0 PHhxvzlvwn 00Vn PHhxvzvmn 'Y}YeAS]NN}-Ng YNkQNt^ WT[O'Yx[lx[buR(udkNel vv(We}u`l_StSGR0QY_m O_Freud.S K(u PHhxvzle|^yux[vHQE 1\vQUt|^y^y}uvuNebKN NRRe|vsNv}W!j_si 2001 0SY l W>ygx[[Le Play \]N}v[^b_Ka@b2Lvxvz NS_ON^x[[Bronislaw Malinowski(WTrobriand\@b2Lv0uΑxvzI{GWpW Tv PHhxvzHamel, Dufour & Fortin,1993 0 (WNASN}R  W>ygx[RTx[>m Mb2Nek\ PHhxvzK(ue \]miS]ylvܕOULvc ;N5_xvzar2eQxvzvsa4XW K(u PHhxvz \OUL2L;NhQb_vt0N NSw/f PHhxvzvwna}0 V0 PHhxvz-laN 00 PHhxvz(W- gNlavN (W WgQx[Xomn2003 SRobert K.Yin@bW 0Case Study Research 0Nf 1u\i[@bo-N2001 cQN Nvޞ N ccxvzv- } \ PHhxvzl xvz--N gN Pyr%R͑vCQ } sSN PxvzvOUL0[v}TL0[vRgUCQ0#P}njeS}TLv/0NSˑxvz|vsvnGR 001.xvzvOULOcOULvb__ sS 0NN 00 0/fN 00 0(WT 00 0YUO 00NS 0pN 0I{OUL _N1\/fNY1\xxvzOULv,g0 002.xvzv}TLxvz-Nvk P}TLxvzvv g\`OvlaR_\(Wxvz{ WgQ@barjvN` N &NS_ckxveT20 3.RgUCQdkp[UO 0 PHh 0v9h,gOUL _N/fN P(W PHhxvzNY1\O1Yxvziq`vOUL0 004.#P}nje}TL/Sˑx|vsvnGR;NOc PHhxvzݑ \xvzOUL0}TLS2LmeQnjeƖ_ |_dkYUO(WnjeRg N ZPNTtS/'`vRg _N/f PHhxvz(W-Bfar`Y[njeRgvWy0 N xvz gvb]vMR&Nl gNUO]wQS(uOUQ PHhxvzvxvzb] FONScONN8^@bvb] Ok^R PHhxvz)Rv2L N P PHhxvz@bvb] gN N~^ޞ 001. OU}YvOULar YOU}YvOUL 1\/fN0Rxvz/fߍOUL gܕ0 002. /f}Yv 0F} 0ar/f}Yv 0F} 0 NgNbyY]vaXWKa bHQeQp;Nv_@bP6R0 003. gia'`NwQ gH_'`ar gia'`NwQ gH_'` @bG0RevrlBf gvuZP/f_jg N/fZ0 gb]vxvzN[g_xvzgRvvv NNYg|vuNeKNYvNN _N_Xa9exvzv z^bR0FOvu`OZPNNNRN_ /f_}cl gvޞ0 004.ccxvz-Nv;NL_ccck(WxvzvpL .zccvRS\@bd \vvܕNNSnj Ɩ-N(WN PS{tv{ WgQ0 005. NwQOP NarVNMRv`l "uuOP xvzaOcOea NVawvvId0  N jO^He^ 001.xqQ Tj8hvunje6eƖ[b (W2LnjeRgxvz1XJTd[KN Sˊxvz PHhcOVKa gEQRccxvz PHhKNޞ`l0 002. N҉j[l\ N TnjeOnbel@b6eƖKNnje }1uNNj8hpSIe_ cؚnjenˑ1XJTKNSO'`0 003.wgS (6:<>DFJLPRXZ^`bdhlnprtvx~  " ׽h*hWB*OJo(ph hWOJo(hW5OJ\o(hW5CJ\o(jhWCJUmHnHu hWo(hW5\o(h*hWCJ$aJ$o(h*hW5CJ$\aJ$o(>(*68:>FLRZ`djlptx$a$ $WD&`a$gd*L@NNP   ( b  p$NdHVDWD^`Na$ $dHWD`a$$dHa$$dHa$$a$  " & j   z |  j  J`*$L28F(@FlDhhWB*OJo(ph"h*hW5B*OJ\o(phhW h*OJo( hWOJh*hWB*OJo(phhW5OJ\o( hWOJo(DFxt$+dHWD^+`a$$@dHVDWD^`@a$$dHWDK^`a$$6dHWD?^6`a$$0dHWD^`0a$4FR. z !\"""X#$0dHWD^`0a$$dHa$$dHWDK^`a$$`dHWD^``a$D6 B | !!^"n"""""\#j###6T6f66667X778899: :::;(;;;;;Z<j<<<h=|==> >$>&>(>>>??íԙ&hhW5@B*OJ\o(ph*jhhW0J@B*OJUph hhW@B*OJo(phhW@OJo(hW5OJ\o(UhhWB*OJo(ph hWOJo(:X##P6667X7789::;;;;V<<d==$HdHWD^`Ha$$dHVDWD^`a$$dHVDWD^`a$$/dHWD^`/a$gd1$0dHWD^`0a$xvz_wgSte P PHhxvzN z MbEQR0[teccxvzsabLpva0 004.`Xa}KNNxvz_ \xvz`Xa} 2L[te0P[vc Mbk^REQRccxvz͑ޞNxvzsa0 005. TQ֊xvzSNN TQ֊SNcaN z 2NekБnxvzOUL&qޞ &N|vU\QR[SLvxvzV{eu0 N0 PHhxvznjeƖKNelRg N njeƖel\i[ 2001:81-90 1.eNeNvg͑(u (WepvQNvnjeOncOPOI bXRnjeKN(u0(WteԚ NvP

wZԚ NQsvezI{0 2.jHhjHhSN PHhxvzvvQNnj On#P} Y gR0D}T~0g1XJTnje0 PNe0LNfI{ I{0 3.*NJ*NJ/f PHhxvzg͑vW,gnj OnKNN vQ-Ng8^v PHhxvz*NJ /fl\e>e_v SYN.z*NJ/f(WNkwBf-N*NJNMOVT{vel /fl\e&qޞ_v*NJ OYN\BfQ/fN.z^8Ock_vOUwSg P[fpP}iSvOUL .zOUwSSN-p PHhxvzvNR0 4.vc[Nvc[SNZPp PHhxvzSN.zIdvOn Y[gp0W-;mR0]^\Omi0Ye[ TvQN^ygyx[-NvRgbS SN\Op.z-vRgel0 002 ͑v[Oc(W͑v 04X@b 0-N b/f(W TN P PHh-NcvQNvL]eQ_vRgUCQ Vp PSV ͑[1\pN.zBf^R N TvRgel 1ue.zRgel N*YSSaQ PHhxvzlܕ_v@b gpL Vdk͑[S/fN.z!kvRgel0 mQ0 PHhxvzv*QޞP6R PHhxvz(W[a(u-N VvQwQ gKNyr_ N gvQ*Qޞ:ޞÞIQĖ0!||v1996299sey 1998389I͑e 2002213-215 N *Qޞ 001.njeƖJPNwQH_'`xvzSK(uT.znjeƖel vQ PHhnjevb__06eƖ z^&Nl gV[vb__ Vdk njeƖ NvvuJPNwQH_'`0 002.SN \ PHh\OmeQvRg:e1ue PHhxvz@bƖvnjevvuYCQ Vdk S \ PHhvOUL\O gaNmeQvRg:e0 003.Nb{O gvQPygyx[vW-N Y2kku͑vxvz (WƖ̀ofnjeeb PHhxvzyr%R g(u VvQRgmeQfecQy@S _NSN/fiQ PbiQ PN Nv PHh0WԚbD}T~ ;N/f wbPxvzvOUL/fN0 PHhxvz֖nfMK(u(WTx[yb[RvW FON gvQ*QޞSP6R /fygWԚpO  N NMO W-N^zfysYu'`O[OP]Lp\KN PHhxvz Snje sey 1998 Yexvzl SS NWSQHr0 Robert K.YinW \i[o 2001 PHhxvz SS _zfeS0 giOt 2000 PHhxvzSvQ(WYexvz Nva(u -Nck'Yx[Yex[xvz@b;N}0 >yg]\OxQ 2000 SS]gQ?e>y@S|vU\ܖ>y0 s#k 1995 Yexvzl\Lxvz 0Yexvzel֊ 0x[ zYePg}xvz1XJT0 si 2001 PHhxvzl http://stmail.fju.edu.tw/~a8610011/master/casestudy.htm Xomn 2003 '`xvzt֊a(u SS _tQHr0 I͑e 2002 Yexvzl SS _tQHr0 ÞIQĖ0!||v Yexvzl SS +^'Yfт0 Feagin, J.R., Orum, A. M., & Sjoberg, G.Eds. ,1991 , A Case for the Case Study, The University of North Carolina Press. Merriam, S.B.1998 , Case Study Research in Education. San Francisco:Jossey-Bass. Yin, R.K.1994 ,Case study rdsearch:Design and method (2ndEd). Newbury Park, CA: Sage. Hamel, J., Dufour, S., & Fortin, D.1993 , Case study methods. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.  L]eQ_RgUCQL]eQ- 傮U \N PHh NPNr PHhpN PRgUMO N_NblaRneP[UMOS!k}v0Rgv^;Ny^v SkugQv P%ReHh GRp1zKNs#k 1995 0 OYNcggN WOmivz-rRpO pcgvQz-rR EeRgrOmig"uTv.Url GROD(Wdkz-rRcg Nv PHhxvzSpNL]eQ_vRgUCQsi2001 0     PAGE  PAGE 8 PHhxvzl PHhxvzvW,gi_ PHhxvzlvwn PHhxvz-laN00000000 PHhxvznjeƖKNelRg PHhxvzv*QޞP6R P}00000֊ PHhxvzva PHhxvzvvv PHhxvzv^W PHhxvzvyr_ ccxvzv- } xvz gvb] jO^He^ njeƖel njeRg!j_ PHhxvzv*Qޞ PHhxvzv:ޞ MR0000 =>>???@@AAABBC DtDDE EFFFFdH$dHVDWD^`a$$GdHWD^`Ga$gd1$HdHWD^`Ha$??@@ABAAAABBBBCCCD&DxDDE EVEEFFGGGGGGGGGGH$H@HBHHHHHHVIhIzIIIIIIIIIJFJHJJJҹҰҪҡҰҪҰҰҦҰҪҰҰҡҪҪ hW>*o( hWo(hW hWOJhW>*OJo(hW5OJ\o(hhWB*OJo(ph hWOJo( hhW@B*OJo(phhW@OJo(hW5@OJ\o(N@NDNFNJNLNPNRN0dHWD8^`0dH & FdHJJLJTJVJZJJJJKK KJKKKKKKKKKLxLzLLLLLLLL>N@NBNFNHNLNNNRNTNXNZNfNhNjNlNnNpN|N~NNNNNNNNNûûûûñÑ hWCJo(h0JmHnHuhM1h a h a0Jjh a0JUjhT$UhT$jhW0JUhW6H*] hW6] hWo(hWhW6OJ] hWOJ hWOJo(8RNVNXNjNlNnNNNNNNNNNNNNNO O O"O2O4ODOFOVO$a$`WD`` &`#$gdM1NNNNNNNO O O"O2O4ODOFOVOXOhOnO~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOPPPP hW@o( hWo(hW hW@o($VOXOhOjOlOnO~OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOPPPPP$a$PP0dHWD8^`001h2P. A!"#$%S H@H gQe1$$CJKHPJ_HaJmH nHsH tH$A@$ -k=W[WFiF h\ 9r G$CJaJ)@1  ax0@LU^gpqr{   J*,- :>BDF0@LU^gpqr{   b#&)-02568:<@DGIKORVXZ]_cegijklm|}18Do< :t ]qr~ P ) _  = q . Y e M1n.vNV-3yX_$gjpMNOWj &NZZ     !,-./56@AJK^_noz{(000000000000000000000000000000000000000000(000000000 0 00000000000000@0@000@0h00@0h00@0h00@0h00@0I0 0I0 0@0@0h0 0\vh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`acegF& HtD%tEt6:ttttx tttVtttJ'*tHtt  tt*xt)t&tZ8t%JeJt,t t+<'<t t-xt.t:itJt8t5t1ttt>Jft/<e<t t=ttB*tAct@Vti tDx:t?ttC-T-tf*tGtm/cm4mm|[m Zm[m[ms\BBPNRR9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsplace8*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsCity9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsState ms{}0@7:>BCGCHns#%&).23Cuz +/089?s{\a pr}  - 6 A B K ` g m | } ~     # 6 B G O Q ( / ^ c   < B p v - 2 X Z d i LQ03mp-0uxMSU[   #$.27x}WY^c#(fjorLOVWij  %&*.MNRV]Z\      ./6?AIKU_moy{  :@y=>FG:;&'78  IM-.9:U Z " : = o p ` c j k mnfg|}rs+,=AUV@FJKAZ      ./s3ss33sss3sssssssss3ssss3s3s3sss3sssss3sssss3ss3ss333333sss3-5Z      ./4Z      ./jjd&#0^`0o(  ^` 0 ^` . ^` .`  ` ^` ` 0@  @ ^@ ` .   ^ ` . ^` 0 ^` .jjZE        WNT$M1 a*1@U @@6UnknownGz Times New Roman5Symbol3& z ArialC.e0}fԚPMingLiU 1h&&||& . .!?!),.:;?]}    " % & ' 2 t%00 0 0 00000013468:<>@BDOPQRTUVWZ\^ \]d([{  5 0 0 00000579;=?ACY[][NN2QHX?12# z>yg]\Oxvzel\L0000 00000c+^s#k0+^tomNef>ygx[bNef>ygx[bN gRNmi{t|s#k Oh+'0 0 p|    Hҵ{G|u@skMD@@@@ @@@@@½ҦѮvGRY@ѮvtomNormal8H[|ǰ|H[|ǰ|ѤHAȨƷ~޲ztRY3Microsoft Office Word@2~@ @fv@vx՜.+,0 X`lt| . N   !"#$%&'()*+,-./013456789;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`acdefghiklmnopqtRoot Entry FyvData 21Table:NWordDocument2bSummaryInformation(bDocumentSummaryInformation8jCompObjm  FMicrosoft Office Word MSWordDocWord.Document.89q